• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
WRAP

WRAP

Western Regional Advocacy Project

  • Donate Now
  • Get Email Updates
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • About
    • 40 Years of Fighting
    • History
    • Mission
    • Strategy
    • Members
    • Board / Staff
  • Campaigns
    • Business Improvement Districts
    • House Keys Not Sweeps
    • Legal Defense Clinics Project
    • Homeless Bill of Rights
    • Oregon Right To Rest
    • Without Housing
    • Street Outreach
  • Organizing Tools
    • Without Housing Organizing Toolkit
    • Homeless Bill of Rights Campaign Manual
    • WRAP Organizers Manual
    • WRAP Artwork
  • Resources
    • Pipe Dreams and Picket Fences Report
    • Art in Action Power Point Slide Show
    • Hobos to Street People
    • House Keys Book
    • Political Education
    • Legal Research
  • Media
    • Newsletters
    • Blog
    • Hobos to Street People Art Show
    • Street Newspapers
    • Sweeps Gallery Videos
    • Videos
  • Support Us
    • Donate
    • Become a Monthly Sustainer
    • Volunteer
    • Support WRAP
    • WRAP Newsletters & Updates Sign Up

CARE COURT IS ANOTHER TOOL FOR OPPRESSION. CARCERAL COURTS DON’T CARE.

June 28, 2022 by Jonathan 1 Comment

TLDR: Newsom’s CARE Act (SB 1338) weaponizes care (read: conservatorship) against poor and Disabled people, doubles down on racist and classist systems at the expense of community-based treatment programs and real, affordable housing. 

Newsom’s proposed “CARE Act” (SB 1338) is a cash grab for courts and cops – it represents continued investment into a violent system predicated on white supremacy and classism, giving the police state a shiny new toy that will be used to intimidate and incarcerate poor and Disabled Californians. Essentially, this legislation substantially expands ways that unhoused people with mental health disabilities can be brought into the system, from expanding parties who can petition to refer someone into the court, to creating a new protocol for mandating and overseeing forced treatment. There is nothing voluntary about CARE courts: at every stage that is allegedly “voluntary,” refusal to comply defaults to coercion, ultimately resulting in full-on conservatorship. This legislation does not invest a single dime in expanding or improving community based treatment options, and does not guarantee (nor fund) permanent supportive housing. Most egregiously, this policy continues a documented pattern of mental health laws being used as weapons to criminalize Black and Brown communities. 

Less than two years ago, millions marched across the nation demanding care, not cops, so why are carceral policies like SB 1338 still dominating the legislature? Look no further than the policy’s most powerful advocates: Governor Newsom, the Collaborative Court Association, and the Big City Mayors, along with support from local law enforcement groups and business organizations, make up the stakeholder group for creating “CARE ” courts. Their political agenda has been well documented and on display daily, where they support and enforce traumatic street sweeps that shuffle people from one place to another. They’ve made it abundantly clear that they are concerned with the visibility of the people targeted by this legislation, and so the focus of this legislation is to make those people disappear, whether through forcibly institutionalizing them or by driving them away by using this new court system as a threat. 

Hundreds of thousands of people call the streets of California home on any given night. But these aren’t the “stakeholders” that the Governor, or the Mayors for that matter, want to hear from, and as far as we know that Newsom has an established track record of manipulating and misleading marginalized community members into supporting harmful legislation.  We demand that the Newsom administration do more than thinly veiled token engagement – listen to directly impacted people and the groups they’re organizing with in cities like Los Angeles, Oakland, San Francisco, Sacramento. They do not support this harmful policy. House keys not handcuffs, we need care not courts!

Los Angeles – Services Not Sweeps & Los Angeles Community Action Network 

In Los Angeles, Services Not Sweeps has seen LAPD continually target Unhoused residents in mental health crisis rather than care for them. Being that there’s a disproportionate percentage of Black Angelenos who are Unhoused relative to the number of residents here, CARE Court becomes a new mechanism to target and disappear them into mental health facilities. The County of LA does not have the resources to properly respond to mental health crises, so instituting CARE Court puts vulnerable and precarious lives into the hands of the LAPD, which has a brutal history of targeting and mishandling even simple calls for help in Unhoused communities.

For the Los Angeles Community Action Network: “In Los Angeles, we currently see a slew of increased carceral policies. That includes enhancement, dedicated enforcement of “No Sit, Law or Sleep,” daily property sweeps, and recession-proof budget allocations for sanitation and police. SB1388 is another carceral policy that allows interpretation up in the hands of too many untrained state actors—continuing to increase the cycle of homelessness and incarceration.

Sacramento – Sacramento Homeless Organizing Committee

At Sacramento Homeless Organizing Committee, we have long advocated for dignity and self determination to be integral components of service delivery. Not simply because it’s the right thing to do but because voluntary services are evidenced based as having the most successful outcomes. Creating a new coercive court system instead of investing in voluntary services is a terrifying step for the most powerful people in the state to enact on the rest of us who struggle with mental stability. Court is not an historic mechanism of care, but rather of punishment. We need widespread and significant investment in community based healthcare and into the social determinants of health early in our lives. Housing, community, education, recreation, reducing the stress of poverty, these are the things people actually need and the state should move forward with immediately to alleviate mental health crisis in our state. 

Oakland – Anti-Police Terror Project & Love and Justice in the Streets

During Mayor Libby Schaaf’s tenure, thousands of lifelong Oaklanders have lost their jobs, their homes, and their lives due to her administration’s failures. A 2019 Alameda County point-in-time count of Oakland’s unhoused population reported an eighty-six percent increase between 2015 and 2019, with nearly 79 percent of these individuals reported to be unhoused due to a lack of affordable housing options. The report estimated that 70 percent of Oakland’s unhoused population is Black, compared to 24 percent of the population. In 2018, the UN Special Rapporteur reported that attempts in Oakland to discourage residents from remaining in informal settlements or encampments by denying access to water, sanitation, health services, and other necessities constitute[d] cruel and unusual punishment and a violation of human rights. A audit of the Schaaf Administration’s interventions was released in 2021; it stated that the city’s efforts were “haphazard,” lacking strategy or policy direction. Oakland is a city in the midst of a housing crisis — we demand that the legislature reject SB 1338 and invest in immediately providing increased access to housing and services.

San Francisco – Coalition on Homelessness

The reality for individuals in mental health crisis living on the streets is miles away from the false narrative of treatment resistance behind the formation of a CARE court.  In a recent survey of 600 unhoused people we conducted in San Francisco, we found that those who are experiencing mental health challenges wanted treatment but couldn’t obtain it because of barriers to getting care.  For those who got treatment, it worked while they got it, but they then found themselves in a revolving door that spit them back to the streets.  For people who don’t have the stability of a home, addressing mental health challenges is almost impossible.  What no-one living this is asking for is a court process to navigate them into care.  In fact, the current proposal from Newsom will mean far less funding for the things that work – treatment and housing but a whole lot of money going to courts, lawyers and judges.  We don’t need courts to mandate people into a broken system.  We need system fixes that result in diverse treatment and housing options that truly meet individuals needs.

Human Rights Watch

CARE Court promotes a system of involuntary, coerced treatment, enforced by an expanded judicial infrastructure, that will, in practice, simply remove unhoused people with perceived mental health conditions from the public eye without effectively addressing those mental health conditions and without meeting the urgent need for housing. Under international human rights standards, treatment should be based on the will and preferences of the person concerned. Housing or disability status does not rob a person of their legal capacity or right to personal autonomy. The expansive, involuntary CARE Court process denies these rights. We urge the legislature to reject this bill and instead to take a more holistic, rights-respecting approach to address the lack of resources for autonomy-affirming treatment options and affordable housing.

For More information or to join our campaign contact:
Western Regional Advocacy Project

2940 16TH STREET, SUITE 200-2, SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94103

TEL: 415.621.2533 / EMAIL: wrap@wraphome.org

WEB: www.wraphome.org


[1] https://oaklandside.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Alameda-County-point-in-time-count-2019.pdf

[2] https://daccess-ods.un.org/tmp/3826722.20468521.html

[3]https://www.oaklandauditor.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/20210414_Performance-Audit_City-of-Oaklands-Homeless-Encampment-Management-Interventions-and-Activities.pdf

Filed Under: Advocacy, Blog, California, Call to Action, Civil & Human Rights, Criminalization, Los Angeles, Oakland, Sacramento, San Francisco

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Randy Hicks Hicks says

    June 28, 2022 at 7:26 pm

    Yes I concur what is written here

    Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Footer

Instagram Feed

Does the litany of laws forbidding camping, loiter Does the litany of laws forbidding camping, loitering, trespassing, blocking the sidewalk and panhandling make society safer? https://conta.cc/3ZrNvk5
https://conta.cc/48wWLr8
Welcome to the WRAP-UP! Boise, ID. Video Shows Fam Welcome to the WRAP-UP!	Boise, ID. Video Shows Family Violently Arrested and Severely Injured for Living in Park, and more news from our members.  https://conta.cc/3R8Efzl
https://conta.cc/3r3rHhU
Washington D.C. PRESS RELEASE: Congresswoman Bush Washington D.C. PRESS RELEASE: Congresswoman Bush Re-Introduces Unhoused Bill of Rights https://wraphome.org/
After nearly 30 years of continuous publication, w After nearly 30 years of continuous publication, we have lost our funding. Street Spirit ceased publication on July 1, but we will not give up! Our newspaper is an invaluable source of East Bay news, and a vital resource for the people who sell it. Come party with us to support our effort to relaunch. https://conta.cc/3rifOod
WRAP is Hiring - Member Organizer WRAP was founde WRAP is Hiring - Member Organizer 
WRAP was founded in 2005 by local social justice organizations across the West to bring about real systemic change. We are building a multi-issue, multi-racial and social justice-based coalition which brings organizations together across the local–national divide, thus giving us the strength and experience to make ending poverty and homelessness a national priority. https://conta.cc/3XD5QK9
Celebrating Resistance Relationships June 30, 202 Celebrating Resistance Relationships 
June 30, 2023 * 6:00 - 8:00 pm 
320 West 37th Street, New York, NY 10018
State of the “Sweeps” The politics of encampme State of the “Sweeps”
The politics of encampments and displacement in the “post” pandemic order
Public panel discussion, June 14, 4-5:30pm Communications 120
University of Washington, Seattle
Undercommons Archives Art Show Thursday June 15th Undercommons Archives Art Show
Thursday June 15th 7-10pm 
Adobe Books 3130 24th St. SF
Instagram post 17863401230948820 Instagram post 17863401230948820
San Francisco, CA. Mayor’s Plan to Expand Shelte San Francisco, CA. Mayor’s Plan to Expand Shelter GUTS HOUSING FOR HOMELESS FAMILIES AND YOUTH 
https://wraphome.org/2023/05/31/mayors-plan-to-expand-shelter-guts-housing-for-homeless-families-and-youth/
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Facebook Icon

Facebook Feed

Comments Box SVG iconsUsed for the like, share, comment, and reaction icons
Link thumbnail

Does the litany of laws forbidding camping, loitering, trespassing, blocking the sidewalk and panhandling make society safer?

web-extract.constantcontact.com

The Legal Defense Clinics (LDC) Project aims to strengthen and support the growing movement to decriminalize homelessness by reimagining the...
11 hours ago
View on Facebook
· Share
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email
View Comments
  • Likes: 1
  • Shares: 0
  • Comments: 0

Twitter Icon

Twitter Feed

Twitter feed is not available at the moment.

YouTube icon

Youtube Code

Our Channel

Copyright © 2023 Western Regional Advocacy Project WRAP · Log in