• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
WRAP

WRAP

Western Regional Advocacy Project

  • Donate Now
  • Get Email Updates
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • About
    • 40 Years of Fighting
    • History
    • Mission
    • Strategy
    • Members
    • Board / Staff
  • Campaigns
    • Business Improvement Districts
    • House Keys Not Sweeps
    • Legal Defense Clinics Project
    • Homeless Bill of Rights
    • Oregon Right To Rest
    • Without Housing
    • Street Outreach
  • Organizing Tools
    • Without Housing Organizing Toolkit
    • Homeless Bill of Rights Campaign Manual
    • WRAP Organizers Manual
    • WRAP Artwork
  • Resources
    • Pipe Dreams and Picket Fences Report
    • Art in Action Power Point Slide Show
    • Hobos to Street People
    • House Keys Book
    • Political Education
    • Legal Research
  • Media
    • Newsletters
    • Blog
    • Hobos to Street People Art Show
    • Street Newspapers
    • Sweeps Gallery Videos
    • Videos
  • Support Us
    • Donate
    • Become a Monthly Sustainer
    • Volunteer
    • Support WRAP
    • WRAP Newsletters & Updates Sign Up

‘Criminalizing Homelessness Violates the Constitution’ Report. “the Justice Collaborative has published a white paper, authored by constitutional law scholar Peter Edelman, explaining why the laws criminalizing homelessness around the country, violates the constitution.”

June 4, 2020 by Jonathan 1 Comment

“the Justice Collaborative has published a white paper, authored by constitutional law scholar Peter Edelman, explaining why the laws criminalizing homelessness around the country, violates the constitution.”

SUMMARY: The Justice Collaborative Institute, “Criminalizing Homelessness Violates the Constitution,” May 2020

Local governments are not free to trample the rights of people just because they are experiencing poverty or living without housing. The Supreme Court has held that it is cruel and unusual punishment to criminalize homelessness based on long-standing legal principles that people cannot be punished for their status. Likewise, people without shelter retain fundamental constitutional protections. 

As federal courts have made clear at all levels across the country, treating homelessness like a crime is unconstitutional under many circumstances. In spite of this, American cities have effectively criminalized homelessness through proliferating laws that prohibit camping in public, sleeping in cars, and sitting in public spaces. 

Case law also prohibits targeting homelessness with criminal laws that appear neutral on their face but apply only to people without access to shelter. Crimes that inevitably follow from the condition of living without shelter are also unconstitutional. These principles can protect people from encampment evictions, the seizure and destruction of personal property, and prosecutions for camping, sleeping outside, and soliciting. 

(1) Laws prohibiting sitting, lying, or sleeping in public have been found unconstitutional and constitute cruel and unusual punishment when enforced against people who have no access to shelter. In Powell v. Texas (1968), the Supreme Court found the 8th Amendment prohibits the state from punishing an involuntary act or condition if it is the unavoidable consequence of one’s status or being. 

  • 9th Circuit has twice applied these principles to bar the enforcement of sit/lie ordinances: once in LA in 2006 and in Boise in 2018.
  • In Boise, the DOJ filed a statement of interest arguing that punishing a universal and unavoidable consequence of being human violates the 8th Amendment

(2) Encampment evictions and seizing or destroying property were successfully challenged on 4th and 14th Amendment grounds. Litigation has led to settlements that require jurisdictions to provide adequate notice and shelter options before clearing an encampment, store and inventory any property taken, and seize only property that poses a legitimate public health risk. 

  • Lavan v. City of Los Angeles (2012): unhoused people retain an interest in continued ownership of their personal possessions within the meaning of 4th and 14th amendments. Since Lavan, a number of district courts have applied its reasoning to find that unhoused people have a property interest in possessions such as tents, tarps, blankets, and medications, even when these are kept in public space. 

(3) Prohibitions on solicitation and panhandling have been successfully challenged. 83% of cities restrict or ban begging in public, but these laws have been found unconstitutional in many cases

(4) Supreme Court has long recognized that soliciting contributions is expressive activity protected by the 1st Amendment

  • 7th Circuit reversed an earlier ruling and enjoined Springfield, Illinois’ law restricting vocal pleas for immediate donations of cash
  • Homeless Helping Homeless, Inc. v. City of Tampa, a federal district court enjoined the city of Tampa from enforcing its ordinance banning the solicitation of donations or payment. 

(5) Prohibiting loitering and sleeping in vehicles: The Supreme Court has held that ordinances banning loitering or sleeping in cars are unconstitutionally vague when they do not give clear notice of the prohibited conduct or would allow for arbitrary or discriminatory enforcement.

  • Desertrain v. City of Los Angeles challenged an LA ordinance that prohibited the use of vehicles as “living quarters” because it appeared to apply only to homeless people and not to all the other drivers who also eat food or transport belongings in their vehicles. 

Filed Under: Civil & Human Rights, Criminalization, Homelessness, Report

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Jason says

    July 2, 2022 at 4:20 am

    How about states like hawaii that make you show proof of legal residence just to get an ID card? This is also a violation of my constitutional rights civil rights and liberties, isn’t it?

    Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Footer

Instagram Feed

Does the litany of laws forbidding camping, loiter Does the litany of laws forbidding camping, loitering, trespassing, blocking the sidewalk and panhandling make society safer? https://conta.cc/3ZrNvk5
https://conta.cc/48wWLr8
Welcome to the WRAP-UP! Boise, ID. Video Shows Fam Welcome to the WRAP-UP!	Boise, ID. Video Shows Family Violently Arrested and Severely Injured for Living in Park, and more news from our members.  https://conta.cc/3R8Efzl
https://conta.cc/3r3rHhU
Washington D.C. PRESS RELEASE: Congresswoman Bush Washington D.C. PRESS RELEASE: Congresswoman Bush Re-Introduces Unhoused Bill of Rights https://wraphome.org/
After nearly 30 years of continuous publication, w After nearly 30 years of continuous publication, we have lost our funding. Street Spirit ceased publication on July 1, but we will not give up! Our newspaper is an invaluable source of East Bay news, and a vital resource for the people who sell it. Come party with us to support our effort to relaunch. https://conta.cc/3rifOod
WRAP is Hiring - Member Organizer WRAP was founde WRAP is Hiring - Member Organizer 
WRAP was founded in 2005 by local social justice organizations across the West to bring about real systemic change. We are building a multi-issue, multi-racial and social justice-based coalition which brings organizations together across the local–national divide, thus giving us the strength and experience to make ending poverty and homelessness a national priority. https://conta.cc/3XD5QK9
Celebrating Resistance Relationships June 30, 202 Celebrating Resistance Relationships 
June 30, 2023 * 6:00 - 8:00 pm 
320 West 37th Street, New York, NY 10018
State of the “Sweeps” The politics of encampme State of the “Sweeps”
The politics of encampments and displacement in the “post” pandemic order
Public panel discussion, June 14, 4-5:30pm Communications 120
University of Washington, Seattle
Undercommons Archives Art Show Thursday June 15th Undercommons Archives Art Show
Thursday June 15th 7-10pm 
Adobe Books 3130 24th St. SF
Instagram post 17863401230948820 Instagram post 17863401230948820
San Francisco, CA. Mayor’s Plan to Expand Shelte San Francisco, CA. Mayor’s Plan to Expand Shelter GUTS HOUSING FOR HOMELESS FAMILIES AND YOUTH 
https://wraphome.org/2023/05/31/mayors-plan-to-expand-shelter-guts-housing-for-homeless-families-and-youth/
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Facebook Icon

Facebook Feed

Comments Box SVG iconsUsed for the like, share, comment, and reaction icons
Link thumbnail

Sacramento prosecutor sues California’s capital city over failure to clean up homeless encampments

clbn.us

SACRAMENTO, Calif. — Sacramento’s top prosecutor is suing the city’s leaders over failure to cleanup homeless encampments, escalating ...
1 day ago
View on Facebook
· Share
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email
View Comments
  • Likes: 0
  • Shares: 0
  • Comments: 0

Twitter Icon

Twitter Feed

Twitter feed is not available at the moment.

YouTube icon

Youtube Code

Our Channel

Copyright © 2023 Western Regional Advocacy Project WRAP · Log in